
Sooo… the first images of the USS Enterprise from the upcoming new Star Trek film have been released.
Yep.
If you haven’t seen it, here it is. Check it out.
Now, despite my reservations about the film (I am a huge Trek fan, but an avid avoider of anything attached to J.J. Abrams), I want to talk about this ship they’ve designed.
Because I don’t think it is a very good design. Now, hold on – This isn’t merely me looking and saying, “Ugh – the saucer section and neck of the ship are too far back” (although, they are). I have thought about this a lot.
The ship seems cobbled from two different thoughts of design. The top is a somewhat traditional design, but the bottom explodes into an “organic” design that really doesn’t fit, all curves and flow. The problem with the organic design is that it doesn’t work – neither in the cobbled design or in the concept of what the ship should look like at the beginnings of deep space exploration.
Please understand – The problem isn’t that the Enterprise has been redesigned, it is the redesign they’ve gone with that is the problem.
I knew the ship would be changed at least a little for the film, so I’m okay with that. And, I do appreciate the efforts to keep the ship familiar looking for long time fans. I just don’t think this design works.
The original design of the Enterprise on the TV show seemed very utilitarian, but well balanced. Take a look at the comparison I’ve put together here.
If they were going for an original series sort of look for the movie (which, judging from the costumes, I’m assuming they are), it would have been better to eliminate the ill advised curves that don’t fit with that utilitarian design. These are the first steps of deep space exploration for Starfleet – contours and aesthetics shouldn’t come into play just yet. And if they do, it would seem the saucer section should be modified to match… stretched, maybe, or having it flow into the neck of the ship in the same way the neck is flowing into the base. And, yeah, the whole thing looks squashed. The design needs some of the open areas of the original.
Ah, but maybe modern audiences wouldn’t accept that type of utilitarian design.
Fine.
I offer the 1701-A version as an alternative. Take a look at this comparison.
Note that the design is actually radically updated from the TV series, but the essence remains the same. Here, the designers managed to update without going the organic, curvy route. Sure, there are elements that are more rounded, but instead of trying to evoke an update with forced “flow,” they instead decided to go with what I would call a more sleek look – modified angles (Yes, angles!) give an updated, yet still balanced look to the ship as a whole.
Frankly, looking at it again… I just wish they’d gone with the 1701-A if they were going to take that much of a departure from the original ship.
My two cents.